Contact Us | Jobs And Opportunities | Register/Log-in |

The Global Land Tool Network (GLTN) contributes to the
implementation of pro poor land policies to achieve
secure land rights for all. Read more...

Home arrow Forum

May 17th, 2012

Forum
Login
If you do not have an account, please click here to register
Stay Connected
           
   
Facts
Forum  


 User post
 Moderator post or edited by moderator
Birte Scholz

 
Click here to see the profile of this user
Welcome to Train Ride 2 from your Moderator! - 2008/09/16 03:36 GMT WELCOME!

Welcome to Week 2 of the GLTN Gender Mechanism discussion, or the Ride Two of the Train Ride.

My name is Birte Scholz, and I will be your moderator during this portion of the Train Ride. I am the Land and Housing Campaign Global Coordinator at the Huairou Commission- an international coalition of networks dedicated to highlighting and enhancing the vital work that grassroots, or community level, women make in the field of human settlements.

The Huairou Commission recognizes the importance of integrating grassroots women within key processes, such as the GLTN and the land tools it promotes. It knows that community women, really at the heart of human settlements around the world, must be recognized by and link with processes and programmes that deal with issues concerning human settlements- the key issues being land access, use, ownership and control.

To review, we are on a Train – a continuum of discussion – with our Destination – a finalized a set of criteria and indicators to implement them, in order to assess the gender responsiveness of large scale land tools, the aim of the GLTN.

So far along this Train Ride, we have been brainstorming on potential criteria, based on the integrated criteria developed from a merging of two lines of thought, a grassroots or community perspective, and a more technical or administrative perspective. (Please see Criteria section, within the Forum side bar, to the left, for all sets of criteria developed so far- from the Lukenya meeting, the Bagamoyo meeting, and an attempt at merging the two). We have had a rich discussion during the first Train Ride. Complex issues were touched upon and a number of debates had: Equity vs equality, ownership vs access; formal vs informal systems; legislation vs. Education. Cross cutting were issues of empowerment, political realities of land, development needs, non-homogenous nature of women, and several others. It hs been a good ride thus far!

WHAT WE WILL DO THIS WEEK:

Train Ride 2 will work towards focusing the discussion a bit more around categories or clustering of criteria which will simplify both the finalization of the aspects of criteria, but also the development of indicators or methods for applying the criteria- the measurements which allow us to say whether or not criteria have been met.

Developing categories or clusters of criteria during Train Ride 2 will allow for an easier handling of these and other very complex and intricate details that make up that which is “gender responsiveness”. Clusters or categories of activities will check duplication of ideas and propose the most effective formulation of the complex factors through an easily accessible checklist. The trick is to develop this clustering without over-simplifying the variety of issues that need be considered when determining something is gender responsive.

TO START THIS DISCUSSION:

To start off this discussion, before we take time to get into the next stage based on previous substance, may I ask that we begin by asking ourselves- what do we mean by clustering? ... We know what clustering can achieve- but how do we get there? And what is the ultimate end product?

Do we mean streamlining the criteria into clusters, limited not only in number but also in scope- so that we prioritize, as was suggested last week, those that are universally applicable and most likely to result in positive change?

Or do we rather mean developing criteria clusters, perhaps still reduced in number, but increased in scope- ones that give room for a more specific analysis of the various nuances that women face, as also suggested?
Or perhaps we do a bit of both?
Could we begin this week by thinking in this way, so that all are clear on what we are trying to do this week- and to affirm/hear other ideas on how to get there?

In the following posts, we can build on this by thinking further on the discussions of last week, the various list of criteria and Diane’s tables (which will be posted shortly).
Remember this is an interactive discussion. Developing criteria is not easy- and most likely, not many of us have engaged in such a process before. Let’s take time to think things through, yet at the same time, bear in mind our ultimate destination and the limited time of this journey.

My questions/comments are meant simply to stimulate discussion and at times where appropriate, attempt to summarize and move us forward. Your thoughts and inputs to these questions, as well as any other comments you would like to give, are more than welcome.

I am thrilled to be here this week as your moderator and on behalf of myself and the moderator team, greet you as passengers on this segment of the Train Ride, some continuing from Train Ride 1 and some new to this journey!

WELCOME one and all!
  | | The topic has been locked.

      Topics Author Date
    thread link
Welcome to Train Ride 2 from your Moderator!
Birte Scholz 2008/09/16 03:36 GMT
    thread link
thread linkthread link Re:Welcome to Train Ride 2 from your Moderator!
ROSEMARY WACHIRA 2008/09/17 09:49 GMT
    thread link
thread linkthread linkthread link Re:Welcome to Train Ride 2 from your Moderator!
Bina Agarwal 2008/09/19 08:07 GMT
    thread link
thread linkthread linkthread linkthread link Re:Welcome to Train Ride 2 from your Moderator!
Patricia Chaves 2008/09/19 13:31 GMT
    thread link
thread linkthread linkthread linkthread link Re:Welcome to Train Ride 2 from your Moderator!
Birte Scholz 2008/09/20 20:17 GMT
    thread link
thread linkthread linkthread linkthread linkthread link Re:Welcome to Train Ride 2 from your Moderator!
diane dumashie 2008/09/21 20:53 GMT
    thread link
thread linkthread linkthread linkthread linkthread linkthread link Re:Welcome to Train Ride 2 from your Moderator!
Birte Scholz 2008/09/22 07:46 GMT
    thread link
thread linkthread linkthread linkthread linkthread linkthread linkthread link Re:Welcome to Train Ride 2 from your Moderator!
ROSEMARY WACHIRA 2008/09/22 19:00 GMT
    thread link
thread linkthread linkthread linkthread linkthread linkthread linkthread linkthread link Re:Welcome to Train Ride 2 from your Moderator!
Neezla Kureembokus 2008/09/23 06:41 GMT
    thread link
thread linkthread linkthread link Re:Welcome to Train Ride 2 from your Moderator!
Birte Scholz 2008/09/20 20:23 GMT
    thread link
thread linkthread link Re:Welcome to Train Ride 2 from your Moderator!
Florah Ikawa 2008/09/17 09:50 GMT
    thread link
thread linkthread linkthread link Re:Welcome to Train Ride 2 from your Moderator!
Birte Scholz 2008/09/18 08:28 GMT
    thread link
thread linkthread linkthread linkthread link Re:Welcome to Train Ride 2 from your Moderator!
ROSEMARY WACHIRA 2008/09/18 18:26 GMT
    thread link
thread linkthread linkthread linkthread link Re:Welcome to Train Ride 2 from your Moderator!
Birte Scholz 2008/09/19 06:06 GMT
    thread link
thread linkthread link On tools that are inclusive
Siraj Sait 2008/09/23 14:56 GMT
    thread link
thread linkthread linkthread link Re:On tools that are inclusive
Birte Scholz 2008/09/24 06:34 GMT